#clojure log - Nov 14 2009

The Joy of Clojure
Main Clojure site
Google Group
IRC
List of all logged dates

0:01 G0SUB: hmm, after calling (shutdown-agents) I can't send functions to any agent, even the ones created after calling shutdown-agents. Is there any way to restart the agent system?

0:01 what's the rationale behind using that function?

0:03 _ato: G0SUB: it's so that you can kill the agent threads on exit. If you've been using agents and exit without shutting down their threads the JVM can hang

0:05 G0SUB: _ato: so that's only when I want to shutdown the whole jvm after doing some task?

0:05 _ato: yes

0:05 G0SUB: _ato: makes sense. thanks.

0:11 shoover: GoSUB: why did you want to call it?

0:26 _ato: http://www.google.com/trends?q=clojure%2C+jruby&ctab=0&geo=all&date=all&sort=0

0:26 interesting

0:26 according to that Clojure just surpassed jruby in google searches

0:44 tomoj: I so wish google gadgets were in clojure

0:45 with the STM

0:45 I don't have a clue what the fuck the concurrency semantics are for wave gadgets

0:45 the land of refs, atoms, and agents is so simple and easy...

0:46 maravillas: making anything in particular, or just fiddling?

0:46 tomoj: well, both I suppose

0:46 I'm working on a wave implementation of the game "springfield"

0:47 which is, everyone takes turns saying state capitals, and the first person to say "springfield" wins

0:47 maravillas: heh, i see :)

0:47 tomoj: but I realized turn-based was un-wave-y, and now that it's not turn-based, concurrency issues are much more likely I think

0:48 and I have no idea what's going to happen if two people make a guess at the same time

0:48 google seems to just say that gadgets should not rely on a linear and predictable state, whatever the fuck that means

0:48 STM transactions and snapshots are so awesome!

0:49 at least we can write our robots in clojure

2:27 somnium: how to hint overloaded interface methods with deftype?

2:29 nm, on assembla, not getting it working though...

3:44 michaeljaaka: hello

3:44 What is wrong with that?

3:45 (doto (proxy[Thread][] (run[] (

3:45 dotimes [_ 10 ] (

3:45 (println "Hello World ")

3:45 ))

3:45 )) (.start))

3:45 REPL gives

3:45 #<CompilerException java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Method 'doto' redefined (NO_SOURCE_FILE:407)>

3:45 user=>

3:52 _ato: michaeljaaka: you have an extra pair of parens around the println

3:52 (run[] (dotimes [_ 10 ] ((println "Hello World "))))) <-- if you write it like this it's more obvious

3:54 dunno what your doto being redefined is about though, you should be getting a null pointer exception

3:55 (cause println returns null and you try to call it with the extra set of parens.. you can't call null)

3:58 michaeljaaka: I'm just plaing with abstract classes and interfaces

4:00 wow

4:00 thanks

4:00 It works now

4:01 I'm using proxy to make sure that I undestand how to use it in diferent situations

4:01 I have a code in Java to be integrated with Clojure

4:01 that is why I'm more thinking in terms of java than clojure

4:01 but once I interface the code in Java with Clojure

4:02 I will be more playing with thinking in terms of Funtional Programing

4:03 _ato: thanks again, it just works like a charm

7:05 spuz: god, such miserable weather today

7:05 at least it's a good excuse to stay indoors :)

8:40 cgrand: rhickey: hi! I'm just starting to experiment with deftype. Shouldn't specifying ILookup opts out IKeywordLookup?

8:42 rhickey: cgrand: It should, but doesn't opt out of IKeywordLookup, which is used for keyword call sites. This is a bug

8:42 got a small test case?

8:43 cgrand: not yet, I want to try to implement persistent vectors

8:45 and had a problem with ILookup (on my side) so I dug into the source and saw that as a potential bug when implementing maps

8:57 lisppaste8: cgrand pasted "IKeywordLookup not opted out" at http://paste.lisp.org/display/90382

8:59 cgrand: rhickey: ^^ test case

9:02 do you want a patch or you fix it yourself?

9:02 rhickey: cgrand: almost done

9:02 cgrand: great!

9:08 rhickey: cgrand: ok, it's up

9:09 I'm still not happy with this auto-impl stuff

9:12 chouser: because of how it must be implemented?

9:21 rhickey: chouser: it just seems icky and hardwired. Because of the inheritance in the interfaces, it can get tricky to tell when someone is implementing something via implication

9:22 I wonder also if nothing/full-map is sufficient granularity

9:22 and as we spoke of before, if you implement map you lose keyword lookup for fields, so we need to expose that

9:23 currently IDynamicType/getDynamicField

9:23 * rhickey would like patch to add protocol name to protocol fn doc string

9:26 rhickey: hrm. looks like protocol fn docs aren't even flowing through anymore

9:37 chouser: 3

11:09 Bjering: Hello, I have a newbie question re the state of clojures performance

11:09 I made this (horrible I know, its on purpose...) fib function: (def fib (fn [x] (if (<= x 1) 1 (+ (fib (- x 1)) (fib (- x 2))))))

11:10 and (fib 40) takes 40 sec on my machine

11:10 While the Java version:

11:10 public static int fib(int n)

11:10 {

11:10 return n <= 1 ? 1 : fib(n - 1) + fib(n - 2);

11:10 }

11:10 Takes 2 sec

11:11 Am I doing something wrong or did I just use something that isnät that well optimized in Clojure=

11:11 ?

11:14 chouser: Bjering: numbers are boxed by default in Clojure. Check the interop page and the google group for discussions of primitive number types and math.

11:15 Or, better yet, find a more interesting problem to solve first (rather than fib), and then optimize that if needed.

11:24 spuz: Bjering: have a look at: http://clojure.org/java_interop#toc35

11:24 Bjering: chouser: Thank you, found this http://www.mikeperham.com/2008/12/13/clojure-vs-ruby/ and tried the version with (int n), doubled the speed. I agree I should fins a more interesting problem, just getting started! :)

11:24 spuz: And also read the sections about primitives and coersions

11:24 Bjering: spuz, will check

11:32 slyrus: so, I had made an aborted attempt to ask this the other day, but swank-clojure doesn't seem to be working for me. Well, that's not strictly true, the *inferior-lisp* buffer works, but the REPL doesn't.

11:32 anyone else seeing similar?

11:33 should I not be using slime-fancy?

11:36 the-kenny: slyrus: It works with slime-fancy. Does *inferior-lisp* display any errors?

11:36 slyrus: the-kenny: no, although it occurs to me I might be loading the wrong slime. hang on a sec...

11:38 nope, same problem...

11:38 If I type: 3, I get 3 back. If I type (+ 3 4) it hangs.

11:38 the-kenny: Sounds strange

11:39 slyrus: yeah, and only in the slime fancy repl. in inferior-lisp, it's fine.

11:40 the-kenny: hm.. I used the fancy-repl with Common Lisp, I haven't changed anything in the config, but my clojure-repl isn't fancy... If I had this problems, I would try to disable the fancy-stuff.

11:51 Qvintvs: is there a function like take that works from the back of the collection instead of the front?

11:53 devlinsf: ,(reverse [1 2 3])

11:53 clojurebot: (3 2 1)

11:55 Qvintvs: hrm, well I suppose I could do (reverse (take n (reverse col)))

11:57 Chousuke: (doc butlast)

11:57 clojurebot: "([coll]); Return a seq of all but the last item in coll, in linear time"

11:57 Chousuke: hmm

11:57 there was something else too.

12:36 hamza: Are clojure numbers always BigInteger? is this a correct way to determine is a varible is a number (instance? java.math.BigInteger obj) ?

12:36 rhickey: ,(doc number?)

12:36 clojurebot: "([x]); Returns true if x is a Number"

12:37 hamza: thanks you..

12:37 *thank

13:00 spuz: is there a parallel version of doseq?

13:40 djork: I have implemented something like Clojure's proxy with Lua in Objective-C

13:40 Lua *and* Objective_C

13:41 thanks for the inspiration to all of Clojure's many geniuses

13:44 hamza: is there a way to turn a map in to vector [key1 val1 key2 val2...] reverse the effect of (apply hash-map [:a :b])?

13:47 devlinsf: ,(vec {:a 1 :b 2})

13:47 clojurebot: [[:a 1] [:b 2]]

13:47 devlinsf: ,(into [] {:a 1 :b 2})

13:47 clojurebot: [[:a 1] [:b 2]]

13:48 devlinsf: ,(apply concat (vec {:a 1 :b 2}))

13:48 clojurebot: (:a 1 :b 2)

13:50 ambient: heh, the best criticism of Haskell i've seen so far: "if I have to understand category theory to write a program that

13:50 does IO, IT IS A NON STARTER!

13:51 hamza: devlinsf: thank you..

13:52 Chousuke: I think calling monads monads and trying to explain them through category theory is the problem :P

13:52 spuz: I'm not sure what category theory is but it would seem to me to be the same as complaining that you have to understand functions to write a program. If that's a feature of the language then guess what, you have to learn about it :p

13:52 ambient: the first way i understood functions was go here, then come back

13:53 it's pretty easy-peasy

13:54 spuz: I think my point is that different languages demand different background knowledge but ultimately you're always going to have to engage your brain at some point even in the simplest of languages

13:54 ambient: well, C was quite straight-forward for me to learn without any programming or mathematics background

13:55 Chousuke: C doesn't have functions though. it has procedures.

13:55 ambient: it's mostly just loops 'n jumps

13:55 Chousuke: functions are a very special kind of procedure :P

13:55 ambient: correction, jumps 'n conditions

13:56 gravity: spuz: Have you written any haskell?

13:56 spuz: gravity: a long time ago, very breifly, I guess I never got as far as category theory, or at least I didn't understand it :p

13:56 Chousuke: Sometimes when reading the haskell tutorials I get the feeling everyone involved in developing the language is a theoretical mathematician.

13:58 spuz: If some code is well broken down into functions that do well defined things, would you call that well factored code? well modularised?

13:58 well functionalarised?

13:58 Chousuke: I mean, as far as I understand, monads define how to compose a class of operations.

13:58 ambient: i don't think there is a visible line that separates computer science from math, it's more of a continuum

13:59 Chousuke: which makes a lot of sense, to me.

13:59 it's just a bit difficult to visualise how it all works :/

14:00 spuz: ambient: I agree though I think the way people's brains are wired can be pretty distinct between mathematicians and computer scientists which can make crossing over painful

14:00 gravity: Chousuke: That's really all they do. The various monad tutorials give a lot of metaphors to visualize it (like assembly lines and whatnot)

14:01 Chousuke: gravity: yeah, but it's still difficult to bring to the "real" world :P

14:01 gravity: Chousuke: Yeah, I agree, which is why I stopped trying to beat my brain against haskell :-)

14:01 Chousuke: the maybe monad is easy to understand, but anything beyond that...

14:02 ambient: i can't really justify spending a lot of time learning Haskell when from the practical standpoint other platforms and languages _seem_ so much more productive.

14:02 Chousuke: the fun thing is that I have succesfully written monadic Clojure code once but even though it worked and was pretty nice I don't think I could understand why anymore.

14:02 it just doesn't stick :/

14:03 haskell probably is productive once you get into it.

14:03 ambient: a probability that i'm not willing to bet on

14:04 gravity: There's a number of libraries for clojure that use monads, like the parser combinator library. I'm not sure how good they are though.

14:04 spuz: heh, reading about monads, they seem to relate to what I was looking for just now. It seems they provide a 'functional' way of doing regular imperative sequential work

14:04 Chousuke: ambient: yeah. the real problem seems to be that haskell is completely unusable until you start getting it :P

14:04 ambient: clojure is exactly what i want from a language, except faster than the best ever optimized C code :P

14:04 spuz: maybe 'monadic' was the word I was looking for :p

14:05 Chousuke: you can't even experiment with it because the compiler yells at you.

14:05 it's nice that the compiler can tell that a program makes no sense but sometimes you need to see it fail to understand why :P

14:08 spuz: they provide a functional way because using a monad, you can define how operations are composed... and for imperative code, the monad "just" has to impose sequentiality. it kind of works around the problem that some things aren't really "functional" at all.

14:08 spuz: Chousuke: I see

14:13 ambient: (my quote was from this rant: http://www.xent.com/pipermail/fork/Week-of-Mon-20091109/054578.html)

14:21 hiredman: clojurebot uses fnparse

14:21 seems ok

14:24 hamza: hiredman: what for clojurebot uses fnparse? i always thought its just a read eval loop?

14:28 hiredman: clojurebot: where do you use fnparse?

14:28 clojurebot: where is your source code

14:28 hiredman: hamza: it uses fnparse for factoid lookups and definitions

14:29 hamza: oh ok.

14:29 arj: is there any updated instructed on how to use slime? I just tried installing and I get a bunch of wierd errors

14:29 seems like all the emacs+slime+ubuntu guides are outdated

14:30 ambient: what kind of weird errors?

14:30 gravity: arj: I used the instructions on the clojure wiki

14:30 ambient: the easiest method for installing clojure/emacs for me on ubuntu would be: emacs > ELPA > clojure-mode from ELPA > M-x clojure-install

14:30 requires: ant & git

14:31 gravity: ambient: That's what I used as well.

14:31 hiredman: ~emacs

14:31 clojurebot: emacs is best configured for Clojure with instructions at http://technomancy.us/126

14:31 gravity: arj: I had to undo the ubuntu tutorial stuff with that method as well to make things work properly

14:31 arj: thanks

14:36 ambient: i might've to clone drscheme for clojure :/

14:41 Scriptor: Hi everyone, I'm having some trouble installing vimclojure

14:42 I compiled clojure-contrib with the -Dclojure.jar flag, but it still gives a ClassNotFoundException when I try to compile vimclojure for the prettyprinter

14:42 ambient: -Dclojure.jar=../clojure/clojure.jar ?

14:43 or wherever your clojure.jar is located

14:43 Scriptor: yep, did that

14:43 so clojure-contrib compiles fine

14:43 ambient: vimclojure should compile just fine if you have the .properties file right (iirc)

14:44 how that can be done is in the readme

14:44 Scriptor: yes, I did that as well

14:45 ambient: well, that should be working then :/

14:45 Scriptor: used the absolute paths to clojure and contrib,

14:45 ambient: i used relative ones

14:45 ../clojure/ etc

14:46 clojure.jar = ../clojure/clojure.jar for example

14:46 arj: I don't get it, so I got slime working. And when I do a C-c C-k I just get: compilation finished and nothing in the repl?

14:47 ambient: arj did you do M-x slime?

14:47 Scriptor: ok, I just changed it to relative paths, still doesn't work

14:47 arj: ambient: yes

14:47 ambient: arj try running your functions from the repl

14:47 arj: I just have (+ 1 2)

14:48 and that works fine ;-)

14:48 ambient: C-x b *SLIME <tab> :p

14:48 it doesn't print everything in the repl iirc

14:48 gravity: arj: Try something like (println (+ 1 2))

14:48 arj: it just says 0 compiler notes

14:49 aha that works

14:49 thanks gravity!

14:49 gravity: arj: No problem.

15:23 spuz: Hi all, I've posted an article about my clojure mandelbrot app: http://developmentjungle.wordpress.com/2009/11/14/rendering-the-mandelbrot-set-in-clojure/

15:23 Any feedback would be greatly appreciated!

15:35 ambient: well, the layout is very nice, and the article is descriptive, informative and has a nice logical progression

15:36 you might be interested in this: http://github.com/ztellman/penumbra/blob/master/src/examples/mandelbrot.clj

15:38 erikcw: I'm trying to get my feet wet with Clojure. To start, I'm trying to import a Java class for demo purposes. The class is not part of a package. Just "public class Demo" with a few methods inside. Why (import '(Demo)) everything seems to go fine (I get nil returned), but then when I try (.aMethod Demo) I get Unable to resolve symbol: Demo in this context. What am I missing?

15:39 krumholt: erikcw, is aMethod static?

15:40 then you would have to do (Demo/aMethod)

15:40 if not you would have to create an object of Demo (.aMethod (new Demo))

15:40 hiredman: erikcw: (import 'Demo)

15:41 somnium: is it necessary to quote java classes?

15:41 hiredman: if Demo was in a java package like java.io you'd do someting like (import '(java.io Demo))

15:41 erikcw: krumholt: no, it's not static

15:42 hiredman: somnium: no

15:42 but import, until recently, was a regular function

15:43 so (import Foo) would try to resolve Foo and fail, because the whole point of import is to set it up so Foo resolves to the java class

15:44 erikcw: I removed the parens form the import and it started working

15:44 somnium: in ns macro?

15:44 hiredman: somnium: in the ns macro you never needed to quote

15:44 somnium: at repl (import com.klass.Foo) creates a Foo in current ns

15:44 never saw quoted java class before today :)

15:44 hiredman: "... import, until recently, was .."

15:45 somnium: how recently is recenty?

15:45 hiredman: the last two months maybe?

15:46 somnium: usually you see :import directives in the ns macro, which, as I said, never required the quote

15:46 erikcw: usually java classes are in a package

15:47 erikcw: hiredman: this was practically a hello world... :-)

15:47 I'm still in Python land

15:48 hiredman: erikcw: hello world is java -jar clojure.jar -e "(println \"Hello World\")"

15:48 no import needed

15:49 erikcw: well, it wasn't exactly hello world, but it didn't seem like enough for a package either. I'm just trying to figure out all the Java interop stuff

15:50 hiredman: erikcw: java interop is, essentiallly, transparent, so I wouldn't bother "learning" it, just use it when you need it

15:51 using import on Demo is kind of silly anyway

15:51 erikcw: what would be the preferred way of getting into my Demo class?

15:51 hiredman: you can just write Demo in your code and it will refer to the class Demo

15:51 like in java, import just aliases the package qualified name to a shorted name

15:52 java.io.File => File

15:52 Demo => Demo is silly

15:52 erikcw: but when I restart the REPL and try (new Demo) without the import, I get an "Unable to resolve classname" error

15:52 hiredman: you never have to use import at all if you don't mind writing out long class names

15:53 erikcw: but I would need to put Demo in a package right?

15:53 hiredman: erikcw: and after import it works?

15:53 ,File

15:53 clojurebot: java.lang.Exception: Unable to resolve symbol: File in this context

15:53 hiredman: ,java.io.File

15:53 clojurebot: java.io.File

15:54 hiredman: ,(import 'java.io.File)

15:54 clojurebot: java.io.File

15:54 hiredman: ,java.io.File

15:54 clojurebot: java.io.File

15:54 hiredman: ,File

15:54 clojurebot: java.io.File

15:54 hiredman: could be a default package issue (which is where classes with no package get stuffed)

15:55 erikcw: ,default.Demo??

15:55 clojurebot: java.lang.ClassNotFoundException: default.Demo??

15:57 chouser: clojure doesn't really support the default package

15:57 hiredman: like I said, don't bother with java interop until you have a real use for it, because it won't be an issue

15:57 until you need something from some apache library or something

15:59 * ambient has had performance issues without using java style arrays

16:00 hiredman: performance issues are not the samething as interop issues

16:00 ambient: if java style arrays are considered as interop (and I'm going that) when without them, writing idiomatic clojure, the program would be a lot less performant

16:01 *doing

16:01 hiredman: it's not "java style arrays" they are java arrays

16:01 ambient: ok

16:01 hiredman: and using them, reading them, writing them, is all easy as pie

16:02 ambient: not really

16:02 it seriously clashes with functional programming style imo

16:02 hiredman: ,(into-array [1 2 3])

16:02 clojurebot: #<Integer[] [Ljava.lang.Integer;@1fdc6f6>

16:02 hiredman: ,(into-array Integer/TYPE [1 2 3])

16:02 clojurebot: #<int[] [I@1c803ae>

16:03 hiredman: ambient: well, that is an impedance mish mash that I don't think can be done away with

16:03 ambient: this is what i'm doing at the moment: http://bitbucket.org/amb/clojure-snippets/src/tip/src/amb/synth/engine.clj

16:03 and think that's pretty bad

16:03 it might be just my limitations

16:05 hiredman: what is bad about it from an interop stand point?

16:05 there are java arrays as first class values

16:05 ambient: you said it, the impedance mish mash

16:05 hiredman: taking part in the macro system

16:05 etc

16:06 I mean, what else could you possibly want?

16:07 ambient: if i knew the answer to that question, i'd already done it

16:07 but im not satisfied with this current solution

16:07 hiredman: have you looked at changing stuff like osc-type-sin to an inline function?

16:07 ambient: it's not clojure, i think i just have to think about this problem a bit more

16:07 hiredman: I hate to see math traveling across function calls

16:08 ambient: i can't really make it functional because its realtime and every value could be changed at any given time

16:08 it constantly takes in user input

16:09 hiredman: *shrug*

16:11 you've seen rich's recent talk thats up on infoq?

16:11 ambient: the jvm lang summit?

16:12 hiredman: yeah

16:12 ambient: i heard there were light-weight java classes coming at some point in the future for clojure

16:12 yeah i watched it

16:13 hiredman: so clojure is for describing processes, not for writing “functional” programs

16:14 it's that functions are the most composable way to describe parts of a process

16:14 ambient: he also talked about discretizing the world into steps, which is exactly what im doing

16:15 between each step, the state can be changed by the user and then fed unto functions

16:15 it's just that i'm doing that 44000 times a second at minimum

16:17 somnium: ambient: are the 'light-weight java classes' deftype or lighter still?

16:17 these rumors

16:17 hiredman: a java class is a java class

16:18 the only difference would be the amount of ceremony involved in defining one

16:18 somnium: true

16:18 ambient: somnium probably

16:18 somnium: I wish gen-class was lighter weight

16:18 often some ugly java apis want you to subclass some mutable thing that they're packages can mash all over

16:18 hiredman: somnium: write some macros

16:20 http://gist.github.com/34229

16:20 somnium: I've been unable to get equivalent performance with gen-class :(

16:20 remotely equivalent even

16:20 slyrus_: ahh... thought i was losing my mind for a moment there. the changes that cause slime/swank-clojure to break are in slime, not in swank-clojure

16:21 hiredman: somnium: gen-class is not a performance construct

16:21 slyrus_: 2009-10-28 is good, slime HEAD isn't...

16:21 hiredman: it is for interop

16:21 somnium: I know, I guess that's what I wish there was, though maybe its better it doesnt exist

16:21 hiredman: gen-class generates a stub for each method that in turn calls the clojure function that backs it

16:21 ~performance

16:21 clojurebot: http://clojure.org/java_interop#toc46

16:21 somnium: because people would use it for evil

16:22 hiredman: deftype and reify will both generate methods directly (no stubs)

16:22 somnium: but you can't subclass concrete types

16:22 hiredman: will and do, I should say, if you are following the new branch of clojure

16:22 somnium: ? using edge but reading assembla

16:23 I guess it hasn't caught up? assembla says only interfaces

16:23 hiredman: edge?

16:23 somnium: new

16:23 how many branches have defprotocol right now?

16:23 that one

16:23 hiredman: somnium: the will and do was not a reply to you, but a continuation of what I said earlier

16:24 somnium: where do you need to extend a concrete superclass?

16:26 I think there are a few possible work arounds for that case

16:27 somnium: I can get by with an interface, but it still would have to mutable, so I already bit the bullet on tiny .java file

16:27 just added a toclojure button that makes a shiny persistent map when the mashing is over

16:27 hiredman: somnium: it is very easy to get to mutable stuff in clojure

16:28 of course there are the thread safe constructs like atoms and refs and agents

16:28 somnium: yes, but not easy to write fast performant classes that let other apis mash on them

16:29 hiredman: somnium: reify lets you create volatile fields

16:29 or at least it did at some point

16:29 slyrus_: looks like addc5be70a489cdc8ed555a2fed7273040da196e is the offending slime commit

16:29 hiredman: you can also just close over an array

16:30 somnium: well, I shouldnt really complain, 80 lines of java and everything else in persistent datastructures isn't a bad deal

16:30 if deftype/defprotocol gets fast enough maybe clojure-encoders will be fast enough to bypass the 90 class hierarchy in the driver some day

16:31 hiredman: you really shouldn't complain until you've reify+volatile fields or closing over an array

16:31 tried

16:31 spuz: ambient: thanks

16:32 somnium: wasnt aware of volatile fields

16:32 spuz: I know there are plenty of other examples of the mandelbrot fractal in clojure. I've not seen that one before though

16:32 somnium: googling now

16:32 hiredman: somnium: it's on the new new assembla page

16:33 but I don;'t know if they made the final reify cut

16:33 ambient: spuz it's plotting mandelbrot with the gpu :)

16:33 somnium: hiredman: its on the new new page but no mention in reify, that I see...

16:34 suggested resource?

16:34 hiredman: reify as mentioned on the datatypes page doesn't saying anything about volatile locals

16:34 somnium: the reify docstring

16:35 github hates firefox for some reason

16:35 spuz: ambient: I expect it's several thousand times faster than my version then :)

16:37 somnium: is reify in a package?

16:37 er ns

16:37 other than core?

16:38 chouser: it's in the 'new' branch

16:38 somnium: I have, from yesterday, with deftype and defprotocol

16:39 but reify isn't there

16:40 hiredman: looks like reify in Compiler.java has a slot for fields, but it is not used

16:40 build is called with null

16:40 http://github.com/richhickey/clojure/blob/new/src/jvm/clojure/lang/Compiler.java#L5431

16:41 GRRR

16:41 why does github not work in firefox these days?

16:42 I cannot even select text

16:42 anyway, there is a comment that says "//todo - setup volatiles"

16:42 so we'll see

16:45 slyrus_: great... of course the patch that breaks slime/clojure is a 2661-line monster...

16:46 somnium: slyrus_: once a month or so I try to upgrade slime with a fresh .emacs.d, it hasn't gone well for a while

16:46 slyrus_: hopefully its coming to elpa soon

16:47 slyrus_: what is elpa?

16:47 somnium: emacs lisp package archive

16:48 isn't that the recommended way to get clojure these days on emacs?

16:48 spuz: hiredman: You mean half that page is missing? I don't think it's just github, the clojure api page is cut off half way through as well on firefox.

16:48 ambient: it's an old firefox bug afaik

16:49 hiredman: spuz: no, I mean I can see the text, I just cannot select it

16:49 and there is no syntax hilighting

16:49 ambient: perhaps they have disabled with javascript?

16:49 +it

16:49 spuz: hiredman: strange, I can see nothing but whitespace after line 1908

16:49 slyrus_: somnium: recommendend shmecomended... I'd like things to work out of the HEADS of various repos, at least most of the time.

16:49 That was true until 10/31..

16:50 hiredman: spuz: I have a similar issue with core.clj

16:50 ambient: yeah, doesn't work for me either. just blackness after 1/3 of the page

16:50 hiredman: blackness?

16:50 I get whiteness

16:50 ambient: *shrug*

16:50 hiredman: all of Compiler.java is there

16:50 I just cannot select and copy any of the text

16:51 sdeobald: Is there a clojuresque way to append to a list? Like: http://gist.github.com/234800

16:51 hiredman: sdeobald: don't

16:51 sdeobald: Or should one always use a vector in that case?

16:51 hiredman: lists are for prepending

16:52 sdeobald: Right.

16:52 hiredman: vectors are for appending

16:52 sdeobald: Cool.

16:52 hiredman: you could actually make list appending lazy, I guess

16:54 sdeobald: Yeah, I was wondering if that existed as a library function (or contrib) -- though it makes sense that it doesn't.

16:55 hiredman: the other issue with github is if I allow all of github's javascript on the only computer I have with flash installed, firefox locks up for a minute or two

16:55 sdeobald: I doubt it

16:56 sdeobald: s'cool. This is one of the many known issues of working through sicp in clojure, I guess. :)

17:07 hiredman:

17:08 kanak: sdeobald: you could use concat to lazily append the second onto the first. But if you're appending extensively, it's time for a different data structure. :)

17:11 ambient: bah, i have a problem with git "error: Entry 'ClojureCLR/...' not uptodate. cannot merge" tried git reset --hard and git checkout . but wont work :/

17:12 trying git pull gives that error

17:15 aah, it might be just that git is broken on windows

17:41 rhickey: protocol call site caching is up!

17:41 will be in effect when no :on interface is specified

17:41 chouser: please try with your finger trees

18:01 chouser: "queue" test: letfn+reify 2151, defprotocol 6234, now 5380

18:02 split test: letfn+reify 2351, defprotocol 3824, now 3552

18:04 hiredman: are there no obvious bottlenecks?

18:04 chouser: concat test: letfn+reify 1699, defprotocol: 1958, now 1679

18:05 that's it for the tests I've been running regularly

18:05 hiredman: like if you run it through a profiler do you see certain hotspots?

18:06 chouser: hiredman: I had done that in working it down to the "letfn+reify" versions mentioned above.

18:07 There are a few areas I can proabaly still target, esp. on the split test

18:07 I haven't done any profiling since switching to defprotocol.

18:08 hiredman: I am just wondering if defprotocl might have a set of hotspots

18:08 chouser: I've been entrusting rhickey with that end of things. ;-)

18:09 hiredman: so say we all

18:10 somnium: am I crazy? I just built new and reify is not in 'user

18:10 chouser: it's a special form

18:11 somnium: ... so no doc string?

18:11 ah, ok

18:11 chouser: I guess not. but (reify) should return an object

18:12 somnium: it does

18:12 hiredman: where can I find the doc string you mentioned to read?

18:13 dpthfltr: just an idea.. someone should make a clojure DSL for the OpenLaszlo platform. That would be sooo badass and would be something that other non-java languages couldn't do as well.

18:14 there.. I dropped a killerapp idea on you guys now I'll go away for 6 months and when I come back hopefully it'll be ready ;)

18:14 somnium: ooh, I didn't know pandora was openlaszlo

18:14 dpthfltr: walmart.com too

18:15 it uses an XML/JS based language so it's all web standards, no bogus custom language like Adobe uses

18:15 somnium: dpthfltr: I tend to visit pandora more often than walmart.com ;)

18:15 ambient: hi folks, im having trouble in converting from java code to clojure: http://paste.pocoo.org/show/150687/

18:15 dpthfltr: it's declarative programming. You code it once in this XML DSL and then it compiles a javascript and a flash version

18:15 ambient: trying to generate anonymous object that has a callback function

18:16 somnium: doesn't adobe have something like that?

18:16 ambient: here's the reference: http://code.google.com/p/jrtaudio/source/browse/trunk/examples/src/OscillatorBank.java

18:16 dpthfltr: no adobe doesn't have anything like that... they push Flash everything they don't support native JS

18:16 somnium: hmm, walmart site looks like any rails/django, pandora is badass though

18:16 hiredman: somnium: it was a guess

18:17 somnium: ok

18:17 hiredman: just made me think I was crazy for half an hour :)

18:17 hiredman: sorry

18:19 somnium: np

18:21 ambient: im trying to understand proxy. shouldn't this work? (.foo (proxy [] [] (foo [] 1)))

18:22 hiredman: nope

18:22 proxy doesn't let you create new methods

18:22 reify does

18:22 ambient: so it's only for actualizing interfaces? ok

18:22 (doc reify) ==> :(

18:22 clojurebot: Excuse me?

18:22 ambient: ,(doc reify)

18:22 clojurebot: Titim gan éirí ort.

18:23 hiredman: clojurebot doesn't have the special handling needed for special form's docstrings anyway

18:24 ambient: i just did git pull for clojure today and (doc reify) is missing from my repl also

18:24 so im guessing gen-class is what i'm looking for

18:24 hiredman: it's possible that doc's special handling of spcial forms has not been updated for reify

18:25 which makes sense, because the special handling of special forms just points you to the clojure website, which doesn't document reify anyway

18:25 ambient: reify is only on new branch

18:27 ambient: "implements one or more interfaces" can it implement zero interfaces and just construct an anonymous class?

18:27 hiredman: last I check it could

18:27 ambient: eg. would (.foo (reify [] [] (foo [] 1))) work?

18:27 hiredman: checked

18:27 ambient: ok

18:28 ty

18:29 chouser: but I think that requires runtime reflection. That is, it works but will never be as fast as java interop can be

18:31 hiredman: java.lang.NoSuchMethodError: clojure.lang.RestFn.<init>(I)V strikes again

18:32 chouser: no, that doesn't work... Can't define method not in interfaces: foo

18:32 hiredman: hmmm

18:33 somnium: oddly, the inferior lisp buffer blows up when I load new branch, but slime gets started somehow anyway and it seems to work

18:33 *shrug*

18:34 qed: come back clojurebot!

18:34 hiredman: somnium: you might need to recompile contrib

18:35 ,(reify [] (.toString "foo"))

18:35 clojurebot: java.lang.ClassCastException: java.lang.String cannot be cast to clojure.lang.IPersistentVector

18:35 somnium: yeah, I started doing that since yesterday

18:35 hiredman: ,(reify [] (.toString [] "foo"))

18:35 clojurebot: #<sandbox$eval$reify__3467 foo>

18:35 hiredman: ,(reify [] (.toString [] "foo") (.bar [] :baz))

18:35 clojurebot: java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Can't define method not in interfaces: bar

18:35 hiredman: I see

18:36 wooby: ,(doc reify)

18:36 clojurebot: Pardon?

18:37 hiredman: is there some interface generating compliment to deftype?

18:38 chouser: gen-interface is as close as we've got at the moment

18:38 there will be something with more deftype-like syntax I think

18:39 hiredman: ,(deftype Pair [a b])

18:39 clojurebot: DENIED

18:40 hiredman: *zing*

18:40 rhickey: chouser: thanks - where are those tests?

18:40 one thing that will not be sped up by the call-site caching is higher-order use of protocol fns

18:41 chouser: rhickey: sloppily noted here: http://github.com/Chouser/finger-tree/blob/master/notes.txt

18:41 rhickey: is that the case in the first 2 tests?

18:41 hiredman: hmm

18:42 chouser: (reduce consl (EmptyTree nil) ...)

19:09 rhickey: so if might it be worthwhile to generally replace (reduce consl ...) with (reduce #(consl %1 %2) ...) when consl is a protocol method?

19:10 qed: http://github.com/technomancy/leiningen/blob/master/README.md

19:10 hiredman: :(

19:12 ambient: if i feed a clojure function to a gen-class constructor, what is its type?

19:12 chouser: clojure.lang.IFn

19:12 ambient: cheers

19:13 chouser: though I guess you can take your pick:

19:13 ,(supers (class #()))

19:13 clojurebot: #{java.lang.Object clojure.lang.IMeta clojure.lang.AFunction clojure.lang.Obj java.io.Serializable clojure.lang.AFn java.util.concurrent.Callable java.lang.Runnable java.util.Comparator clojure.lang.IFn clojure.lang.Fn clojure.lang.IObj}

19:35 chouser: putting the protocols :on interfaces is faster than not, but not as fast as the call-site caching

19:38 arj: I have a simple question, how do change the classpath of the repl in Emacs?

19:39 ambient: you mean namespace? (ns my.new.namespace)

19:40 somnium: arj: or add-classpath?

19:40 ,(doc add-classpath)

19:40 clojurebot: "([url]); Adds the url (String or URL object) to the classpath per URLClassLoader.addURL"

19:40 arj: I have a library in the current folder that I want to add

19:40 like the java -cp

19:41 somnium: arj: M-x clojure-project / swank-clojure-project make it easier

19:41 arj: ok I'll try

19:41 somnium: but (add-classpath "~/libs/foo.jar") will work by hand

19:41 er, probably no shell expansions I guess

19:42 ambient: if you want to make it permanent to ~/.emacs then "(dolist (d (list "c:/stuff/lib" "c:/more/stuff")) (add-to-list 'swank-clojure-classpath d))

19:42 "

19:42 arj: aha

19:42 thanks!

19:44 damn this clojure stuff is insanely cool :-)

19:48 ambient: seems i can't have gen-class and other random clojure code in the same file?

19:48 trying to gen-class and after write clojure code to use that class fails

19:48 somnium: ambient: did you compile it?

19:49 _ato: it should work okay if you compile it

19:49 ambient: yeah but the gen-class is different from the file name and namespace

19:49 somnium: I think the :name parameter determines the final classname

19:50 ambient: im using (gen-class) instead of (ns foo.bar (:gen-class))

19:50 _ato: ah, I haven't tried that combination

19:50 ambient: so the problem is that (compile amb.synth.rt-impl) wouldn't find the class needed

19:51 when the file it resides in is amb.synth.audioloop-rt

19:52 _ato: hmm.. I would have thought (compile amb.synth.audioloop-rt) would do it

19:52 ambient: it gives classnotfound

19:55 here's the code http://paste.pocoo.org/show/150699/

19:56 Draggor: How do I load a java class?

19:59 somnium: ambient: hmm, it looks like you could put gen class in the ns (which I've gotten to work, no idea about out of ns)

19:59 ambient: yeah, it's what i'm trying to do now

20:00 somnium: ambient: are the defs at the top to be the state?

20:00 ambient: not of the gen-class, no

20:00 somnium: if you have state you need to an -init somewhere to set it

20:00 scottj: Is there a more idiomatic way to write (for [_ (range 3)] (rand-elt "abcdefgh")) than that and (take 3 (repeatedly #(rand-elt "abcdefgh"))) and (map (fn [x] (rand-elt "abcdefgh")) (range 3))?

20:00 _ato: ambient: hmm... your code is actually working for me

20:01 (once I stripped the references to stuff I don't have)

20:03 ambient: http://gist.github.com/234896

20:04 somnium: scottj: maybe (def *random-letters* (repeatedly #(rand-elt))) and then (take n *random-letters*)

20:04 or (dotimes [_ n] ...)

20:05 ambient: _ato ok, i got to try that and start from there

20:05 somnium: Ive never seen for or map used with their bindings ignored

20:09 ztellman: just finished a clone of asteroids, if anyone's interested: http://github.com/ztellman/penumbra/blob/master/src/examples/asteroids.clj

20:12 ambient: were there some problems in naming files "rt-impl.clj" ?

20:12 looks like (use foo-bar) tries to look for foo_bar.clj

20:13 and thus... naming audioloop-rt.clj might screw up gen-class

20:13 qed: what is rand-elt?

20:15 scottj: qed, random element from collection

20:15 qed: is that in a special library or something?

20:16 scottj: qed, clojure.contrib.seq-utils

20:17 _ato: ambient: ah yeah. I think it's because java doesn't like hyphens in class names, so you should put namespace foo-bar in foo_bar.clj

20:18 ambient: i wonder how do i reset namespaces in emacs/clojure/slime?

20:18 sometimes there are leftover functions that annoyingly interfere

20:19 _ato: M-x sime-quit-lisp M-x slime ?

20:19 ambient: tried M-x slime, nope

20:19 _ato: s/sime/slime/

20:19 ambient: cool, slime-quit-lisp works, thanks :)

20:20 somnium: you can use ns-unmap if there's only one or two

20:21 technomancy: ambient: re-invoking M-x swank-clojure-project will do it if that's how you launched it.

20:21 _ato: hmm... looks lie there's also a slime-restart-inferior-lisp

20:21 ambient: nah, not using swank-clojure-project

20:21 even though i perhaps should

20:21 technomancy: you should, unless you're either hacking clojure itself (or contrib) or are just playing around with Clojure.

20:22 somnium: I love being to able to jump from a project in new to 1.0 in seconds

20:23 technomancy: don't know how I used clojure without it

20:24 technomancy: sweet.

20:29 _ato: yeah, that doesn't pick up on new jars in lib/, so I don't use it as much

20:32 Draggor: is this a valid string for add-class? "file./somedir/another/"

20:32 add-classpath*

20:34 _ato: I doubt it

20:34 Draggor: "file:///somedir/another"

20:35 Draggor: _ato: Sorry, my typing is failing, but I don't want to use an aboslute path. Maybe "file://./somedir/another/"?

20:36 _ato: I don't think you can use a relative path

20:36 Draggor: Is there a way to get the current working dir from clojure?

20:36 _ato: (System/getProperty "user.dir")

20:37 Draggor: Thank ye sir

20:39 briancarper: Is it still possible to install swank-clojure without using ELPA and clojure-install and such?

20:40 I'd like to download it to a folder of my choosing and throw some lines in ~/.emacs and have it work. But this seems difficult and undocumented.

20:48 technomancy: briancarper: the master branch of swank-clojure is still un-elpa-ified

20:48 unfortunately it takes a while for things to propagate to the elpa repos; once it makes it in it will be much more straightforward

20:50 briancarper: I'd almost rather things be less straightforward. :( I don't like when things are auto-downloaded and stashed away in places I can't find.

20:50 technomancy: briancarper: the problem is the autoloads for the combination of clojure, swank, and clojure-test-mode are nontrivial

20:50 so it's only straightforward if you don't mind loading them all at emacs boot time, which is not a good general solution.

20:52 briancarper: Yeah, I've noticed the order is hard to get right.

20:54 technomancy: there's not much magic behind elpa, it just puts packages in ~/.emacs.d/elpa/PACKAGE-NAME-VERSION/

20:54 and then it compiles and sets up autoloads

20:54 better get used to it anyway; it's going to be part of Emacs 24.

20:54 briancarper: When it downloads Clojure itself, where does that end up?

20:55 technomancy: the new version puts its jars in ~/.swank-clojure/

20:55 briancarper: Ah, OK.

20:56 ambient: weird. (ns amb.synth.foo (:gen-class :methods [[callback [] Integer]])) (defn -callback [this] 0) and then trying to (compile 'amb.synth.foo) returns IOException

20:56 "system cannot find the path specified"

20:59 *sigh* such fun

21:07 briancarper: ambient: Do you have a "classes" directory for compiled files to be put into?

21:08 ambient: yeah, i created it but it might be in the wrong place

21:09 it would help if i knew where clojure tried to put them

21:10 briancarper: I think it's "classes" relative to the current working directory. Check *compile-path*.

21:10 technomancy: ambient: just check the value of *compile-path*

21:10 ambient: "classes"

21:12 i should probably find out what is current emacs working directory instead of project root or classpath

21:14 technomancy: ambient: ,cd from slime-repl should do it

21:15 st3fan: is there a simple way to iterate over a map like python does, with for key,value in map.values() ?

21:16 ambient: technomancy yeah, putting classes dir to emacs bin directory seems to work, but... i think there might be a better way D:

21:16 briancarper: st3fan: (for [[k v] some-map] (do-something-with k v))

21:16 ambient: there must be a way to change emacs slime-repl working directory on startup

21:16 st3fan: ah that was the syntax i was looking for! :)

21:17 briancarper: ambient: Every time I start Emacs I M-x cd into the right project dir, then immediately start Slime from there.

21:18 ambient: briancarper heh, i already do M-x color-mode-arjen and various rituals

21:18 i'd rather automate the whole thing

21:34 Gul: hi, still learning (at the very beginning), looking for an example of a simple spider (thread pool of 10 connections) for crawling a list of uris, i would be glad if anyone could point me to a simple example

21:45 Jetien: is there anybody out there?

21:45 hiredman: ~ping

21:45 clojurebot: PONG!

21:55 ambient: so how do i set the default directory in .emacs?

21:56 gcv: ambient: I think you can just (let ((default-directory "/your/path")) ...)

21:57 ambient: i dont know how would that work? isn't it usually setting some variable to foo, instead of let

21:58 M-x cd is (swank:set-default-directory "foobar") but that doesn't work like that in .emacs

21:59 gcv: So you're trying to change the current directory for the buffer you're visiting?

22:00 ambient: i just want a way to keep the default location in which clojure created gen-class classes c:/code/clj/classes

22:00 so the working directory of emacs should then be c:/code/clj

22:03 gcv: at a guess I'd say that forcefully setting the default directory will screw things up for you. I think there's a better way to achieve what you want, trying to think of it now...

22:04 ah

22:04 I think I have it

22:05 http://technomancy.us/126 has a mention that setting -Dclojure.compile.path should do the trick for you. just set it to your absolute path, and you should be good to go.

22:07 on another subject, is anyone around who is really good with syntax-quote and unquote?

22:07 I'm trying to transform ['a 'b 'c] into [~'a ~'b ~'c] for intentional variable capture purposes.

22:15 hiredman: gcv: do you have an example?

22:16 technomancy: gcv: tried ['~'a '~'b '~'c] ?

22:16 gcv: hiredman: here's what I really want: (map (fn [x] ?????) ['a 'b 'c])

22:17 fill in the question marks

22:17 hiredman: and what is the output of map?

22:17 gcv: [~'a ~'b ~'c]

22:17 hiredman: it would have to be eval

22:18 gcv: yuck, really? I've been so heavily warned off against eval I didn't even think of it.

22:18 hiredman: no

22:18 not eval

22:18 ,'a

22:18 clojurebot: a

22:19 hiredman: ,`~'a

22:19 clojurebot: a

22:19 hiredman: no difference

22:19 st3fan: gcv, show the full code

22:20 hiredman: so what you want makes no sense, so it's time to widen the scope of the inquery

22:20 gcv: okay, this needs a little explanation

22:20 yes :)

22:20 okay, I'm really really sick and tired of parsing out my own arglists for keyword arguments, so I set out to write something that handles keywords like Common Lisp's lambda lists

22:20 defnk is cool and all, but doesn't work with multimethods

22:20 or (fn [...] ...) forms

22:20 hiredman: god

22:21 just use map destructuring

22:21 I am tired of defnk and apply hash-map nonsense

22:21 gcv: yes, map destructuring is a decent alternative, but isn't quite as DRY as I'd like

22:22 hiredman: ,((fn [{:keys [a b]}] [a b]) {: 1 :b 2})

22:22 clojurebot: Invalid token: :

22:22 hiredman: ,((fn [{:keys [a b]}] [a b]) {:a 1 :b 2})

22:22 clojurebot: [1 2]

22:22 gcv: And you had to write each symbol twice

22:22 chouser: no

22:22 gcv: one other wrinkle

22:22 hiredman: uh

22:22 what?

22:23 gcv: sorry, if you want to specify defaults, you have to write each symbol twice, once in :keys and once in :or

22:23 hiredman: ,((fn [a b] [a b]) 1 2)

22:23 clojurebot: [1 2]

22:24 hiredman: gcv: ok, where is your implementation of this?

22:24 gcv: I want (1) to specify defaults, and (2) to be able to specify an extra optional symbol to be set to an indication if the keyword was passed in. In short, I want it to work exactly like Common Lisp :)

22:25 hiredman: actually, forget it, it's bound to be a complicated macro, and I have no motivation for this, maybe someone else will look at it

22:25 gcv: hiredman: okay, no worries, thanks anyway

22:27 http://paste.lisp.org/display/90409

22:30 st3fan: cool! http://github.com/technomancy/leiningen/blob/master/README.md

22:58 technomancy: st3fan: let me know how it works for you if you try it

22:59 I haven't even announced it and it seems there's a lot of interest, so I guess it's addressing a pain point for clojure developers

23:00 cross: i'm trying to build neman.cells, but having some trouble. does anyone know of a pre-built jar somewhere?

23:01 technomancy: yay; slime/swank-clojure got uploaded to elpa.

23:05 gcv: technomancy: does leiningen support going against non-canonical Maven repositories?

23:07 technomancy: gcv: yeah, I just added that

23:08 it includes build.clojure.org by default, but you can add more in project.clj

23:08 not documented yet, but you just add :repositories {"myrepo" "http://my.repo.org"} to defproject

23:09 gcv: very very nice. thanks for taking this on.

23:09 technomancy: somebody had to do it. =)

23:11 scottj: How do the new branches on clojure and contrib work? Does everything go there first, or just new features, and when are they moved into master?

23:12 Do you guys use the new branches for active development? Is there often breakage between core and contrib and slime and swank when following new?

23:13 _ato: scottj: the "new" branch doesn't actually mean new as in "new things" in means "new" as "new-new" (a feature which was later renamed to reify)

23:13 hiredman: the new branch of contrib is brand new

23:14 gcv: scottj: fwiw, the latest slime and swank-clojure work just fine with Clojure from the 'new' branch.

23:14 _ato: scottj: but yes experiement features that might change completely or may never actually make it into clojure are developed in branches

23:15 hiredman: the new branch of contrib is for contrib contributors to play with features from the new branch of clojure

23:16 _ato: smaller changes and bugfixes go into master, so you can generally rely on master being reasonably stable

23:16 (in the sens of API stability)

23:18 technomancy: clojure.contrib.logging has a really lousy format by default: Nov 14, 2009 8:16:51 PM clojure.contrib.logging$fn__5081$impl_write_BANG___5089 invoke INFO: Compiling leiningen.uberjar

23:18

23:18 any way to tidy that up without pulling in something like log4j?

23:19 never mind; there's really no reason to use anything more complicated than println in this case. =P

23:19 hiredman: I think that is java.util.Logger's format

23:20 time classname method name loglevel message

23:20 _ato: which I think you can override by subclassing java.util.logging.Formatter

23:21 hiredman: :(

23:21 technomancy: yeah, println wins for this. =)

23:21 _ato: yeah, definitely

23:21 hiredman: (binding [*out* *err*] (prn :foo))

23:23 _ato: technomancy: does compiling something with a different version of clojure.jar to the one leiningen is running in work?

23:24 eg. I was thinking about a case where you might want to compile against 1.0 but leiningen is running 1.1 or vice-versa

23:25 technomancy: _ato: currently unsupported, but I think it could be added without too much difficulty with lancet's "java" task.

23:25 _ato: ah good point, so that'd let ant do the trouble of setting up the classloaders and whatever is necessary

23:26 technomancy: yeah, that part doesn't sound like fun to implement

23:26 hiredman: technomancy: because of the way clojure's compiler currently works, if you compile again from the same java process, your compiled classes will be overwritten with garbage

23:27 this is something to keep in mind with build systems

23:27 technomancy: good to know

23:27 _ato: I like the way you're using the ant maven tasks as well. I used the maven API directly in clojars-web and it's horrible

23:27 all that weird plexus stuff

23:27 technomancy: _ato: isn't it a mess?

23:27 ivy was not quite as bad, but still a headache

23:28 hiredman: the differing clojure versions problem means we'd need a separate java process eventually anyway, but I haven't gotten around to that yet

23:28 _ato: it's crazy.. not only do you need to do the usual javaish factory stuff, you have to now lookup factories in a magical container thing

23:28 technomancy: _ato: I completely failed to load Maven.main from within Clojure at all.

23:31 _ato: I didn't try maven.main, I was just trying to use the repository deployment stuff and ended up looking at what the maven-deploy-plugin does

23:31 although half of it is implicit cause things get autowired all over the place by plexus

23:32 http://github.com/ato/clojars-web/blob/master/src/clojars/maven.clj

23:32 technomancy: _ato: so maven has this idea that some dependencies are "test scoped" and don't apply in production

23:32 but I'm thinking that a separate list of dev-time dependencies is clearer

23:33 since they really are two separate lists: things this code needs to run vs things you need to install to be able to hack on it.

23:33 does that make sense to you?

23:34 _ato: hmm... can you give me an exxample of a dev-time dependency? do you mean like unit-testing frameworks?

23:35 technomancy: yeah, swank-clojure is the textbook example

23:35 or other leiningen plugins

23:35 _ato: ah right, and like nailgun for vimclojure and such, okay gotcha

23:36 should that be something that is specified in the project, or should it be implied by using lein swank?

23:37 technomancy: I'm thinking of moving lein swank into a plugin

23:37 so you'd add leiningen-swank to your dev deps if you wanted to use it

23:38 _ato: hmm okay. I'm a bit 50-50 on that. I don't really like the idea of having to modify your project.clj just to run swank on it

23:39 technomancy: you have to do that either way... really the question is rather the dev-time dependencies should be a separate list, or if the main deps list should have a "scope" attribute.

23:39 _ato: I'd put it in a seperate list

23:40 technomancy: it's not "the maven way", but I think it's clearer

23:40 _ato: less boilerplate that way, you just have to specify the scope once for each type of scope, instead of for every dependency

23:40 yeah and it also groups together things that are dev-only vs normal deps

23:40 gcv: hiredman: turns out I was chasing the wrong problem earlier. got it working now

23:41 check out http://paste.lisp.org/display/90409#3 for a flexible way to handle keyword arguments. works with defmethod and plain fn forms.

Logging service provided by n01se.net